I wouldn't care, except this confusion causes two real problems:
Let me clear this up once and for all: Getting paid to REVIEW songs through platforms like SubmitHub? β Totally okay Getting paid to GUARANTEE playlist placement? β That's payola I get paid to listen and provide feedback. Whether I add the song is 100% based on quality and fit. Spotify actually supports this model because it helps artists get discovered properly. The second thing I want to address is his claim that playlists aren't cost-effective for getting fans. I've talked about the strategy for using playlists to grow your fanbase, and you can read all about it in my past newsletter: "Are playlists really growing your fanbase?"β Now that we've cleared that up, let's talk about what musicians really want to know:
Here's what actually matters: After reviewing nearly 50,000 songs, here's the truth: My approval rate [according to SubmitHub] is 20%. Yes, I reject 80% of submissions. But it's not personal (unless you left a hate comment). And why songs get rejected:
100% - could be avoided with a little work before you send a curator your song. What makes me "accept" (the 20% that make it) 1. You actually listened to my playlist - I can tell immediately. When someone mentions a specific song or artist from the playlist, I'm automatically invested. 2. Production that fits the playlist standard - Your song doesn't need a $10K mixing engineer, but it needs to match the quality of other songs. If your bedroom recording sounds out of place next to the rest, listeners might unfollow my playlist. 3. My personal taste - Would I personally replay this? Would I recommend it to a friend? Does it add something special to the playlist? 4. The artist already has momentum - When I see 10K+ monthly listeners (and they didn't come from bot playlists or ad money), I know people actually choose to listen to this. Even if it's not my cup of tea, thousands of fans can't be wrong. 5. The pitch - "Thanks for adding my last song!", "Produced by Taylor Swift", "I'll share your playlist with my 100K followers." How to dramatically increase your chances (from 20% to maybe 80%)
Example of pitches I approved this week: "Hi, this is the latest release of Eli Brown and Anna Reusch! Getting support from various artists like Tiesto, HI-LO and Laura van Dam. Curious to hear what you think!" ""Hi friends! My name is SarahβI'm a Canadian artist signed to 2x Grammy-winning songwriter, Lowell. This is my 6th release & one that I'm super excited about! I'll share press/playlists on my socials!" ""Recorded and mixed at Abbey Road Studios. Hope you like it!" β Let's work together π€
β
|
Every week, get content ideas, music marketing tips, exclusive tools & discounts straight to your inbox! Leave your email below to join 4,500+ musicians on my list ‡οΈ
Welcome [back] to another week of your weekly dose πΆ Every Tuesday, Iβll be sharing tips, updates, and must-know music marketing insights to help you get your music heard! By Finch Bergling π Your Weekly Reel Idea Once again, a trend is taking over Instagram, with videos consistently reaching over 1 million views. These trends highlight the importance of dedicating a few minutes each week to understanding what the algorithm promotes and to following its recommendations. You might spend hours...
Welcome [back] to another week of your weekly dose πΆ Every Tuesday, Iβll be sharing tips, updates, and must-know music marketing insights to help you get your music heard! By Finch Bergling π Your Weekly Reel Idea So yesterday, don't ask me why, I was doom scrolling Instagram reels, and the algorithm showed me a turtle... humping a shoe and making weird noises. The video had over a million likes. One minute later, the algorithm recommended a new video - and it was the exact same one with the...
Welcome [back] to another week of your weekly dose πΆ Every Tuesday, Iβll be sharing tips, updates, and must-know music marketing insights to help you get your music heard! By Finch Bergling π Your Weekly Reel Idea When life gives you hate comments, turn them into a hit song. π Content Summary: In this reel, the artist sits in her living room, singing hate comments she's received as if they're heartfelt lyrics. She shows each comment as a screenshot on screen while smiling and melodically...